Score
Score the product and the process
Scoring the Product:
Have I stated my purpose clearly?
Have I stated the question at issue clearly and precisely?
Have I identified my assumptions and point of view?
Have I been fair-minded in evaluating all points of view?
Have I made unsupported claims?
Is the supporting information clear, accurate, and relevant to the question?
Have I gathered sufficient information?
Are my inferences consistent with each other?
Have I identified assumptions that led to my inferences?
Have I considered the consequences of my conclusions?
Did I present the information in the best manner?
Scoring the Process:
Was the process efficient and effective?
How will I do things better next time?